Symposium: Philosophical Midwifery

Psychoanalysis in the Western Ghats

Issue Editors
  • Ashish Rajadhyaksha
  • Anup Kumar Dhar
Associate Editor
  • Saurabh Chowdhury

This Special Issue of the Journal of Practical Philosophy is a collation of the case records and writings of the Mumbai-based psychoanalyst, Shailesh Kapadia. Shailesh Kapadia is from Gujarat. He practiced psychoanalysis in the financial capital of India, Mumbai. He was trained in “object-relations” in the Tavistock gharana. Psychoanalysis in the Western Ghats is a shorthand for the complex enunciation of the philosophy and praxis of psychoanalysis in the west coast of India. It metaphorizes the western-ness of analytic experience in the Western Ghats. It also metaphorizes the Gujarati-ness of analytic practice informed by British schools. The Trishanku nature of psychoanalysis in India is thus foregrounded. Needless to reiterate, we see psychoanalysis and practical philosophy as apposite exercises.

Table of Contents:
  1. Transference Manifestations In A Hysterical Patient
    Sailesh Kapadia
  2. A Specific Use Of Masochistic Fantasies
    Sailesh Kapadia
  3. Interpretation and Working Through In Transference
    Sailesh Kapadia
  4. Desperate Greed – The Plight Of An Object
    Sailesh Kapadia
  5. On Borderline Phenomena
    Sailesh Kapadia
  6. Modes of Transformations
    Sailesh Kapadia
  7. Use Of Myths By Children In Child Psychotherapy
    Sailesh Kapadia
  8. Some Technical Difficulties In Dealing With Psychotic Patients
    Sailesh Kapadia
  9. Govardhanram Tripathi
    Sailesh Kapadia

Philosophy, Praxis and the Turn to Affect

Issue Editors
  • Deepti Sachdev
  • Latika Vashist
Table of Contents:
  1. Introduction
    Deepti Sachdev, Latika Vashist
  2. On the Age of Hope and Fear: Affective Becoming through Politics in Practice
    Imran AminThe unconscious becomes as an opportunity for subversion amidst incomplete and discontinuous subjectivity, as ‘subject of abject’ embraces ambivalent, unresolved, and dangerous to set future of the world into a hopeful and productive uncertainty.
  3. Eka Nari Sanghathan: A Journey Towards Affective Becoming
    Bhavya ChitranshiIn the dominant discourse, a woman is regarded single not because she does not have family, friends and acquaintances, but because she does not have a husband. Women who are widowed, divorced, separated, deserted, and never-married are commonly regarded as single. This ‘absence of a husband’ in a woman’s life begins to shape the nature of her other social relationships and as a result she is single(d), thereby, marking husband’s absence as a primary attribute dictating and determining her gendered identity and existence.
  4. Caste Away: Recalcitrant Affects and Social Reproduction
    Deepti SachdevWhen she observed who was friends with whom, an old familiar sadness would return. All friendships around her seemed to be along the lines of caste proximity. True friendship, she said, is knowing someone’s dirt intimately and not feeling disgust.
  5. Arriving at Hurt: The Political, The Legal and The Archival
    Sayori GhoshalWhereas, in the powerful hurt could immediately turn into anger and rage and demand retributive action, in the powerless hurt does not necessarily turn into or demand action but continues to be felt and experienced as a condition of existence, that might even no longer be recognizable as hurt per se.
  6. Total Control: Nussbaum’s Normative Account of Anger
    Latika VashistWhat is concealed and encrypted in the destructiveness of anger is an important question to ask. Martha Nussbaum’s response to this question is, however, too simplistic and premised on a linear account of the psyche.
  7. Of Closures and Beginnings: A Phenomenological Study of Familial Relationships
    Ekta OzaBeing invisibilized existentially is more painful than being hated. While hatred involves intense emotions, invisibilizing the other is devoid of emotionality. This hatred is essential for forming an identity.
  8. “Too Late Have I Loved You”: On The Powerlessness of Augustine’s Confession
    Soumick DeIt is this idea of belated love which declares the impossibility of all love to come, while carrying with it the trace of this impossibility. The ‘eventness’ of confession is to capture this moment of divine love which befalls one as grace.
  9. “Beauty Shines Through… As Existence In The Street”: Philosophy And Walking
    Soumyabrata ChoudhuryThe pure walk cannot be distinguished from the great cosmic street insofar they are difficult exercises in making the illegitimate and beautiful utterance, “I walk myself”, instead of assuming the free teleology of saying, “I take a walk.” From this purely functional point of view then, walking is a figure of auto-affectivity and the street a localisation of some threshold.
  10. The woman who thought her husband was a ghost
    Lakshmi Arya Thathachar

From Parrot’s Training to Midwifery

Issue Editors
  • Kalpita Bhar Paul

This symposium emerges from the Practical Philosophy Minor offered as part of the undergraduate BA Liberal Arts program at the School of Liberal Studies, BMU. Throughout the program, the 2024 cohort reflected critically on the relationship between schooling, education, and learning. These reflections did not arise solely from classroom discussions. As an integral part of the curriculum, students spent extended periods working with two organizations deeply engaged in community-based education: Bodh Shiksha Samiti (Bodh) in Rajasthan and Hamar Chinhari Welfare Society (Chinhari) in Chhattisgarh.

We are grateful to BMU for creating a space where such learning could unfold. This symposium marks a significant moment of philosophical midwifery—a process through which students revisit, question, and reinterpret their own educational journeys. In this process, Rabindranath Tagore emerges as a philosophical midwife whose educational thought enables students to identify moments of rupture in their schooling and to imagine education anew as a practice rooted in life, experience, and freedom.

Lack Loss (be)Longing

Issue Editors
  • Kalpita Paul
Table of Contents: (Coming Soon)

From Cracks to Windows

Issue Editors
  • Anish Chakravarty
Table of Contents: (Coming Soon)

Mirror of Being : Canvas of Becoming

Issue Editors
  • Anup Dhar
Table of Contents: (Coming Soon)